Internal Control · 2024
In this section9 topics
- Internal Control — Board Opinion1 item
- Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System1 item
- Internal Control Deficiencies1 item
- Audit Committee & Auditor Observations2 items
- Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit2 items
- Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit2 items
- Related Party Transactions1 item
- Counterparties & Transactions3 items
- Policy & Future Trends3 items
Internal Control — Board Opinion
Summary of the Board's Opinion on Internal Control
The Board of Directors places importance of having a good internal control system. Therefore, it has set up the consistently appropriate and adequate internal control system and risk control system in supervising the internal control system and risk management system of the Company to be appropriate and efficient. This also includes supervising the Company to comply with relevant regulations and laws, preventing conflicts of interest, making a connected transaction as well as monitoring and supervising the operations of the Company, misappropriation or unauthorized use of assets of the Company and protecting assets from leakage, loss, fraud or misconduct. In addition, it is also responsible to ensure the preparation of accurate and reliable accounting and financial reports with full and sufficient disclosure of information in a timely manner.
Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System
Internal Control Framework Used
| Framework | Detail |
|---|---|
| The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO) | From the assessment of the Company's internal control system in 5 components according to the concept of The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of Treadway Commission (“COSO”) The Company did not find any significant deficiencies in internal control system of the Company consisting of 1. Control Environment 2. Risk Assessment 3. Control Activities 4. Information and Communication 5. Monitoring Activities Control Environment The Company has set a good internal control environment by establishing a clear and appropriate organizational structure and assignment of authority and responsibility as well as setting business goals and Key Performance Indicators: KPI to assess performance in accordance with the goals of the organization. The Company has developed the written manual on authorized power and manual on operations for all systems to be used as operational guidelines. In addition, the Company has raised good corporate governance awareness among all executives and employees by establishing a good corporate governance policy, business ethics and the code of conduct of directors, executives and employees of the Company. This also includes continuously supporting activities to enhance knowledge for employees every year to ensure awareness in working with transparency, fairness and taking into account all groups of stakeholders. These are shared to all directors and employees of the Company for their acknowledgment and implementation. There is a clear determination and announcement of penalties if the regulations are violated. These are also shared to external stakeholders through the company's website www.bluebik.com to emphasize that personnel must operate with transparency to prevent corruption and create consciousness for employees to work with morality and ethics. Risk Assessment The Company places importance of risk management under changes that may affect business operations from both external and internal factors. The Company has appointed the Risk Policy Committee (RPC) to supervise the organization's risk management to be in accordance with the goals and at an acceptable level as well as to establish risk management policies in writing before disseminating to employees. In addition, the Risk Policy Committee has scheduled quarterly meetings to assess and manage risks from external and internal factors in all aspects such as strategic, operational, financial, compliance and various events including the risk of corruption. The Risk Policy Committee is required to provide performance report to the Audit Committee and the Board of Directors to ensure that risk management practice of the Company is at an acceptable level. Control Activities The Company has clearly separated the duties and responsibilities of each position. The Company has established policies, operating regulations, operating manuals in writing covering the operations of the Company and defined control measures for all levels including the Company, department, and process to be appropriate to the risks and specific characteristics of the organization. The Company has also reviewed the operational authority manual, regulations and operating manual to be suitable with the current organizational structure and operations. The performance is regularly reviewed to comply with the rules, regulations, authority manual and operational manuals regularly to ensure that the operation is efficient and has an adequate and appropriate internal control system. For transactions with related persons, the Board of Directors has resolved to approve the principle of entering into a commercial agreement in the nature of a transaction between related persons in order to comply with the provisions of the law as mentioned above. The management can enter into transactions or trade agreements that are in the nature of transactions between related persons as defined in the Securities and Exchange Act. However, such transactions or agreements shall be the transactions that a sensible person shall make with other counterparties under the same situation with commercial bargaining power without influence in having the status of a director, executive or related person (transactions with general trade agreements), including ongoing transactions that may occur in the future. The management can set a framework of regulations to be operational guidelines and prepare a summary report of the said transaction to the Audit Committee meeting and the Board of Directors for acknowledgement within a reasonable time. If the Company will enter into transactions with persons who may have conflicts of interest in the future, the Company will arrange for the Audit Committee to consider the appropriateness of the said transaction to prevent the transfer of benefits including disclosure of such transaction information according to the regulations of the Securities and Exchange Commission. In addition, the Company has invested in subsidiaries and associated companies, according to the corporate governance policy of subsidiaries and associated companies, the Company has sent a persons who represents the Company to be a director in each subsidiary and/or associated companies to perform supervisory duties, follow up on various operations according to the business plan as well as to achieve the specified goals and review and improve important policies and plans related to the business operations of subsidiaries and associated companies to be up-to-date and suitable for business conditions on a regular basis. Information and Communication The Company places importance to information and communication system as well as promotes and supports the continual development of the system so that information is accurate and up to date. The Company has applied information technology systems that are modern and efficient with data security from the collection, process, storage and tracking of data to use in operations and to apply important information in management of the executives or other stakeholders accurately and sufficiently in timely manner for making business decision. Also, the Company has established a policy on information technology security and the use of information as well as arrange an intranet system to be a communication channel within the organization for publishing the policy, rules, orders and operational manual including various news throughout the organization. The Company has arranged channels and processes to communicate with employees within the organization. The Company disseminates policies, rules, orders and operational manuals including various news to create knowledge and understanding on various issues accurately and quickly through a variety of communication channels such as intranet systems and e-mail including informal but popular channels such as Line Group to ensure that the message reaches the recipient. In addition, the Company also communicates with stakeholders outside the organization through various media, especially online media which is popular because of the speed of conveying information such as website and Facebook. These channels are accessible and easy to use as the users can search for information via mobile devices immediately and efficiently. The Company has assigned the Investor Relations Department to communicate and organize seminars for investors or stakeholders of the Company. There is an investor relations website to notify useful news to the stakeholders of the Company, such as financial information, stock price information, information for shareholders, analyst information, news center, and investor relation contact, etc. In addition, the Company provides channels for complaints and whistle blowing information or clues via complaint box within the Company or a mail or e-mail. The whistleblowers, complaints and those who cooperate in the investigation of complaints will be protected in the investigation and correction process. Monitoring Activities The Company has established an internal control system that covers all aspects such as accounting and finance, performance, compliance with laws and regulations, and custody of assets. The Company has monitored the performance in the Board of Directors’ meeting and there is hierarchical monitoring system from the Board of Directors to management to regularly supervise the implementation of strategic plan, work plan and projects in the annual business plan approved by the Board of Directors by regularly comparing operating results with predetermined business goals. This is to ensure that the internal control system continues to operate completely and appropriately as predetermined and be able to cope with risks that change in a timely manner at each period. The incident that causes impact to internal control will be reported to responsible person, and in case of any incident that may cause significant impacts, it will be reported to executives, the Executive Committee, the Audit Committee and the Board of Directors within an appropriate time. In addition, the internal control assessment in accounting and finance is audited by a certified public accountant and the results are presented to the Audit Committee for consideration quarterly and yearly. The review results from the certified public accountant view that no significant issue or failure was found. At the Board of Directors Meeting No. 1/2025 dated 19 February 2025, the Board of Directors has considered the sufficiency of the Company's internal control system according to the evaluation form of Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) as applied by management and reviewed by the Audit Committee who commented that control system within the Company was sufficient and appropriate and no significant deficiencies were found that could affect the achievement of objectives of the core of the organization. In this regard, the Company has provided sufficient processes and personnel in order to operate according to the effective internal control system. The prepared reports were accurate and reliable. Business operations were in accordance with the law and related regulations and protected the Company's assets from the use of the Board of Directors, executives and employees inappropriately. Independent Internal Auditor’s Opinion on Internal Control Systems of the Group Kandit Advisory Services Company Limited, which acts as an internal auditor and assesses the internal control system of the Company and its subsidiaries, has performed the assessment of the Group's internal control system with objectives to initially assess whether the organization has an adequate and appropriate internal control system and support the operations of the Group to be able to achieve in the predetermined objectives, goals and/or policies efficiently and effectively. This includes the compliance with the framework of rules, regulations, requirements, frameworks and procedures determined by the Group and/or within the framework of relevant legal requirements as well as and reliable and accurate financial reports and performance reports. The internal auditor has presented the audit results to the Audit Committee and the independent directors which the Group has used the attentions and suggestions to correct and improve processes in consistent with good internal control principles continuously. Auditor’s Opinion on Internal Control Systems of the Group Proud in Pro Company Limited (“Proud in Pro” or “Auditor”), which is an independent auditor of the Group has reported on attention and suggestion on the internal control system from the audit of the financial statements to the Audit Committee meeting. The Auditor conducted audit in accordance with Thai Standards on Auditing, which requires the auditor to comply with ethical requirements and to plan and perform the audit to obtain reasonable assurance whether the financial statements are free from material misstatement or not. The audit procedures are at the discretion of the Auditor including assessing the risks of material misstatement of the financial statements, whether due to fraud or error. The Auditor has considered internal control relevant to the audit in order to design audit procedures that are appropriate in the circumstances, but not for the purpose of expressing an opinion on the effectiveness of the Group’s internal control. The Auditor did not find any significant deficiencies in internal control system of the Group. There are only suggestions for development of internal control of subsidiaries to make internal control of the group of companies more effective. |
Internal Control Deficiencies
Number of Deficiencies
| Metric | Current Year | Previous Year | Two Years Ago |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total number of internal control system deficiencies (cases) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Audit Committee & Auditor Observations
Audit Committee's Opinion Differs from the Board's
No
Auditor Has Observations on Internal Control
No
Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit
Head of Internal Audit
3160
Audit Committee's Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit
The Internal Audit Department is an independent unit and directly reports to the Audit Committee. The Internal Audit Department is responsible for supporting the work of the Audit Committee and the Board of Directors by assessing the adequacy and suitability of the Group's internal control system including monitoring and overseeing departments within the Group to correct and improve any detected failures in internal control system to ensure that the internal control system is appropriate, sufficient and efficient. The Audit Committee has considered to appoint Kandit Advisory Services Company Limited to be responsible perform internal audit and agreed that it has suitability and adequacy to perform such duties. So the Company has appointed Kandit Advisory Services Company Limited to audit and assess the Company's internal control system. Kandit Advisory Services Company Limited has assigned Mr. Thanat Kerdjaroen to be the Chief Internal Auditor and evaluate the internal control system of the Group to ensure that the internal control system is appropriate, adequate and efficient.
Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit
Requires Audit Committee Approval
Yes
Description
According to the authority, duties and responsibilities of the Audit Committee, it has authority to approve the consideration of appointment, transfer and dismissal of the head of the internal audit unit of the Group.
Related Party Transactions
Has Related Party Transactions
Yes
Counterparties & Transactions
Monetary Unit
1
Counterparties with Potential Conflicts
| Name | Person / Juristic Person | Type of Business | Nature of Relationship | As of Date (YYYY-MM-DD) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Arayasab Company Limited | Juristic Person | Real estate | • Having common major shareholders which is Arayakarnkul Family holding 100.00 percent of paid-up capital of Arayasab. The details of which are as follows: 1. Mr. Chaiyasit Arayakarnkul holds 65.00 percent of total shares 2. Mrs. Weerana Arayakarnkul holds 20.00 percent of total shares 3. Mr. Pochara Arayakarnkul holds 15.00 percent of total shares • Moreover, Mr. Chaiyasit Arayakarnkul and Mrs. Weerana Arayakarnkul, directors of Arayasab, are related to the director and executive of the Company. | 2024-12-31T00:00 |
| House of Wisdom Company Limited | Juristic Person | Consulting management services | Mrs. Varinda Thienachariya, a spouse of Mr. Thana Thienachariya, is a shareholders and director a director of House of Wisdom Company Limited. | 2024-12-31T00:00 |
| Southpaw Business Company Limited | Juristic Person | Other management consultancy activities, not elsewhere classified | Mrs. Varinda Thienachariya, a spouse of Mr. Thana Thienachariya, is a shareholders and director a director of Southpaw Business Company Limited. | 2024-12-31T00:00 |
| Mr. Thana Thienachariya | Person | A director of the Company | 2024-12-31T00:00 | |
| Dr. Santitarn Sathirathai | Person | A director of the Company (as of 8 August 2024) | 2024-12-31T00:00 |
Transactions by Counterparty
| Transactions |
|---|
| 4907000.0 · Necessity: The aforementioned transaction is necessary and reasonable, which is the lease of space to be used as an office for the Company's business operations. · Description: The aforementioned transaction is necessary and reasonable, which is the lease of space to be used as an office for the Company's business operations. · As of yesteryear: 4553000.0 · Nature of transaction: The Company leases officer building in 1,2,3,5,6 and rooftop floors · Audit committee opinion: The aforementioned transaction is necessary and reasonable, which is the lease of space to be used as an office for the Company's business operations. The location of the leased area is in an appropriate location, the rental rate, service fees and expenses related to the rental of the space are lower than the total rental rate of other offices nearby and are comparable to the total rent that Arayasab Co., Ltd. recently rented to the third party under general rental conditions. · As of year before yesteryear: 4159000.0 · 957000.0 · Necessity: The aforementioned transaction is necessary and reasonable, which is the lease of space to be used as an office for the Company's business operations. · Description: The aforementioned transaction is necessary and reasonable, which is the lease of space to be used as an office for the Company's business operations. · As of yesteryear: 897000.0 · Nature of transaction: ORBIT Digital Co., Ltd. leases officer building in 4th floor · Audit committee opinion: The aforementioned transaction is necessary and reasonable, which is the lease of space to be used as an office for the Company's business operations. The location of the leased area is in an appropriate location, the rental rate, service fees and expenses related to the rental of the space are lower than the total rental rate of other offices nearby and are comparable to the total rent that Arayasab Co., Ltd. recently rented to the third party under general rental conditions. · As of year before yesteryear: 866000.0 |
| 1200000.0 · Necessity: Membership expense for executive which benefits in developing knowledge, expertise and skills necessary for corporate management. The service fee rates are at market prices offered to another non-related person. · Description: Membership expense for executive which benefits in developing knowledge, expertise and skills necessary for corporate management. The service fee rates are at market prices offered to another non-related person. · Nature of transaction: Expense for H.O.W. Club for a period of 3 years. (Expenses recorded in the financial statements will be gradually recognized over time.) · Audit committee opinion: Such transaction is necessary and reasonable to support the Company business operation and the payment for this transaction is the market price. |
| 320000.0 · Necessity: SSK hires a lecturer who has knowledge and experience in related topics. The price is at market prices offered to another non-related person. · Description: SSK hires a lecturer who has knowledge and experience in related topics. The price is at market prices offered to another non-related person. · Nature of transaction: Hiring a lecturer by Sauce Skills Company Limited (SSK) · Audit committee opinion: Such transaction is necessary and reasonable to support the Company business operation and the payment for this transaction is the market price |
| 70000.0 · Necessity: SSK hires a lecturer who has knowledge and experience in related topics. The price is at market prices offered to another non-related person. · Description: SSK hires a lecturer who has knowledge and experience in related topics. The price is at market prices offered to another non-related person. · Nature of transaction: Hiring a lecturer by SSK · Audit committee opinion: Such transaction is necessary and reasonable to support the Company business operation and the payment for this transaction is the market price |
| 165000.0 · Necessity: SSK hires a lecturer who has knowledge and experience in related topics. The price is at market prices offered to another non-related person. · Description: SSK hires a lecturer who has knowledge and experience in related topics. The price is at market prices offered to another non-related person. · Nature of transaction: Hiring a lecturer by SSK · Audit committee opinion: Such transaction is necessary and reasonable to support the Company business operation and the payment for this transaction is the market price. |
Policy & Future Trends
Introduction
Connected Transaction Policy or Related Transaction
The Board of Directors’ meeting no. 2/2021 dated 21 March 2021 resolved to approve the policy on connected transactions. In the event that the Company or subsidiaries enter into transactions with connected persons, the Company or subsidiaries will comply with the measures and procedures for approval of the transaction in accordance with the rules and the Securities and Exchange Act, regulations, notifications, orders and requirements of the Capital Market Supervisory Board and the Stock Exchange of Thailand Re: Rules for Related Transactions including compliance with the requirements related to disclosure of related transactions.
For the disclosure of transactions that may have conflicts of interest or related transactions or connected transactions of the Company, it will be in accordance with the prescribed rules of the Stock Exchange of Thailand, Capital Market Supervisory Board and the Securities and Exchange Commission. It also complies with accounting standards related to the Company or a person related to the Federation of Accounting Professions. This will be disclosed in the notes of the financial statements audited or reviewed by the Company's auditor, annual registration statement, annual report and any other reports, as the case may be, and disclosure of transactions related to the Company.
Policy, Measures & Approval Process
In entering into connected transactions or related transactions of the Company and/or subsidiaries, the Company will comply with the Securities and Exchange Act including regulations, notifications, orders or requirements of the Securities and Exchange Commission, Capital Market Supervisory Board and the Stock Exchange of Thailand as well as complying with the requirements for disclosure of related transactions and connected transactions and other relevant criteria. The directors, executives, major shareholders and connected persons who have interests in the transaction will not be able to participate in the approval of such transactions.
In the event that such law requires that related transactions or connected transactions must be approved by the Board of Directors' meeting, the Company will arrange for the Audit Committee to attend the meeting to consider and give opinions on the necessity and the reasonableness of such transaction. In this regard, for entering into normal business transactions or supporting normal business transactions which are trade agreements with general commercial conditions and transactions which are trade agreements with commercial conditions different from those made with general counterparties to be in accordance with the following principles.
- Transactions that are trade agreements with general commercial conditions
The Board of Directors has resolved to approve the principle that the management can approve related transactions or connected transactions that are trade agreements with general commercial conditions between the Company and/or subsidiaries with directors, executives, major shareholders connected person.
If such transactions or agreements are the transactions that a sensible person shall make with other counterparties under the same situation with commercial bargaining power without influence in having the status of a director, executive or related person (as the case may be). The Company will prepare a summary report of such transactions to report to the Audit Committee meeting and the Board of Directors meeting every quarter.
- Transactions that are trade agreements with commercial conditions different from those made with general counterparties
Transactions that are trade agreements with commercial conditions different from those made with general counterparties must be considered and commented by the Audit Committee before being presented to the Board of Directors and/or the shareholders' meeting (as the case may be) for further consideration and approval. The transaction must be complied with the Securities and Exchange Act, regulations, notifications, orders or requirements of the Securities and Exchange Commission, Capital Market Supervisory Board and the Stock Exchange of Thailand as well as must be complied with the disclosure requirements of related transactions or connected transactions and other related regulations.The Company will disclose related transactions in the annual registration statement, annual reports or any other reports, as the case may be. The connected transactions with the Company will be disclosed in according to accounting standards in the notes of the financial statements which have been audited by the Company's auditors.
In the event that the Audit Committee does not have expertise in considering related transactions or connected transactions that may occur, the Company will arrange a person with special expertise such as auditors or independent property appraisers to provide opinions on the said related transactions or connected transactions for the Audit Committee and/or the Board of Directors and/or shareholders (as the case may be) as a decision-making information to ensure that the transaction is necessary and reasonable by placing importance of the benefits of the Company.
Future Trends in Related Party Transactions
In entering into related transactions or connected transactions of the Company and/or subsidiaries in the future, the Company will comply with the Securities and Exchange Act including regulations, notifications, orders or requirements of the Securities and Exchange Commission, Capital Market Supervisory Board and the Stock Exchange of Thailand as well as complying with the requirements for disclosure of related transactions of the Company and subsidiaries according to the accounting standards set by the Association of Certified Accountants and Auditors of Thailand and other relevant criteria. The directors will not have voting rights to approve any transactions that they or persons who may have conflicts of interest in any transactions do with the Company.
The future trend of connected transactions will still be in the normal business operations of the Company such as renting of buildings, purchasing goods and services including office supplies, ink and toner cartridges, business cards, brochures, posters, banners, partitions, photographs for employee identification cards, provide services, hiring for goods transportation, advertising and management services (such as advertising management, public relation to the Group etc.), insurance contracting, hiring for training or knowledge development for the company's executives and/or employees, hiring interns or employees. It also includes financial operations such as borrowing or lending, guarantees by the directors for credit lines of financial institutions, etc. The Company will proceed the above transactions with transparency and placing importance to the interests of the Company.
In addition, if there is a related transaction or a connected transaction or there is a change in the terms and conditions relating to the transaction with the directors, executives, major shareholders or connected person, the directors with conflicts of interest will not attend the Board of Directors' meeting on the agenda regarding approval of the transaction.

